Oil & Gas LibraryOILGASLIBRARY.COM Subscribe

Driller's Method Step by Step: Two Circulations, Pressure Behaviour and When to Choose It

Engineers: calculations & HSEDrilling10 min readPublished

Key takeaways

  • The Driller's Method kills a well in two circulations: first circulate the influx out with the original mud, then displace the well to kill mud.
  • The aim is constant bottom-hole pressure, slightly above formation pressure, from start to finish. The choke is the tool; the pressure gauges tell you what to do with it.
  • First circulation: hold drill pipe pressure at ICP = SCR + SIDPP. Second circulation: hold casing pressure constant while kill mud fills the string, then hold drill pipe pressure at FCP = SCR × KMW ÷ OMW until kill mud returns.
  • Worked example: OMW 10.2 ppg, TVD 9,800 ft, SIDPP 480 psi, SCR 550 psi: KMW 11.2 ppg, ICP 1,030 psi, FCP 604 psi.
  • Choose it when you need to start circulating immediately, when weighting material or mixing capacity is short, or when the crew needs the simplest procedure. Expect higher annular pressures than with Wait and Weight.

Educational content only: procedures and operating values vary between companies and wells. Always follow your company’s approved procedures, your supervisor’s instructions and the permits in force at your site.

What the Driller's Method is

The Driller's Method is one of the two standard constant bottom-hole pressure methods taught in IWCF and IADC WellSharp drilling well control courses. Its idea is simple: separate the two jobs. The first circulation removes the kick from the well using the mud already in the system. The second circulation replaces the light mud with kill mud. Two circulations, two simple rules.

Throughout the kill, the target is the same: keep bottom-hole pressure constant and slightly above formation pressure. If it falls below formation pressure, more influx enters; if it rises too far, we risk breaking down the weakest formation, usually just below the casing shoe. The tool that controls bottom-hole pressure while pumping is the adjustable choke: opening it lowers back pressure, closing it raises back pressure.

Before you start: the numbers on the kill sheet

The method needs the same data as any kill (see the kill sheet lesson):

  • SIDPP and SICP after the pressures have stabilised, plus the pit gain.
  • The slow circulating rate pressure (SCR) for the chosen pump at the chosen kill rate, recorded before the kick.
  • TVD and MD, original mud weight (OMW), string and annular capacities, and pump output per stroke.
  • The casing shoe TVD and the leak-off or formation integrity test result, to calculate MAASP.

KMW (ppg) = OMW + SIDPP ÷ (0.052 × TVD)

ICP (psi) = SCR + SIDPP

FCP (psi) = SCR × KMW ÷ OMW

KMW is rounded up to the next 0.1 ppg. Strictly, the Driller's Method does not need the kill mud weight to begin: the first circulation uses original mud. But KMW is calculated at once so mixing can start while the first circulation is under way.

First circulation: removing the influx

  1. Line up and brief. Confirm the choke manifold line-up, the pump to be used, the kill rate and who reads which gauge. Agree the target pressures and write them where the choke operator can see them.
  2. Start the pump while holding casing pressure constant. Bring the pump slowly up to the kill rate. During this short period, open the choke as needed to keep casing pressure at its shut-in value (SICP). Drill pipe pressure responds slowly and through the whole string, so casing pressure is the reference while the rate changes.
  3. Check the drill pipe pressure. Once at kill rate, drill pipe pressure should equal the calculated ICP. If it is different, do not guess: hold the pump steady, investigate, and if the difference comes from an inaccurate SCR, company procedures often accept the observed value as the working ICP.
  4. Hold drill pipe pressure at ICP for the whole circulation. The string contains only original mud, so constant drill pipe pressure at constant rate means constant bottom-hole pressure. Adjust the choke in small steps and wait: a pressure change made at the choke takes time to travel down the annulus and back up the string before it is seen on the drill pipe gauge.
  5. Watch the casing pressure and the pits. If the influx is gas, it expands as it rises. Pit volume increases and casing pressure rises, reaching its maximum when the gas arrives at surface. This is expected: the choke operator is not "losing" the well, the expansion is controlled.
  6. Gas at surface. As gas passes through the choke, pressures can change quickly. Keep holding drill pipe pressure at ICP. When the gas has gone and liquid returns, casing pressure falls.
  7. Shut down and check. After at least one full annulus volume (bottoms up), and normally a complete circulation, slow the pump down while holding casing pressure constant, then shut in. If the influx is out, SIDPP and SICP are now both equal to the original SIDPP.
03006009001,20003,0006,0009,0001st circulationoriginal mud2nd circulationkill mud 11.2 ppgICP 1,030FCP 604SICP 690gas atsurface480casing → 0Drill pipeCasingx: strokes · y: psi
Figure: drill pipe and casing pressure against pump strokes during the two circulations of the Driller's Method, using the illustrative example in this article (SIDPP 480 psi, SICP 690 psi, SCR 550 psi at 30 spm, kill mud 11.2 ppg). The casing pressure peak in the first circulation is drawn as a shape only: its real value depends on the influx and the well.

Second circulation: displacing to kill mud

  1. Kill mud ready. Mud at KMW is mixed, weighed and checked for properties.
  2. Start the pump, holding casing pressure constant at the value read after the first circulation, exactly as before.
  3. Kill mud from surface to bit: hold casing pressure constant. The annulus is full of clean original mud of known density, so a constant casing pressure keeps bottom-hole pressure constant. Drill pipe pressure will fall by itself, from ICP towards FCP, as the heavier mud fills the string.
  4. Kill mud at the bit: switch to drill pipe pressure. When the strokes for surface-to-bit have been pumped, drill pipe pressure should read FCP. From now on, the annulus changes density, so casing pressure no longer reflects bottom-hole pressure. Hold drill pipe pressure at FCP.
  5. Kill mud to surface. Casing pressure falls towards zero as the annulus fills with kill mud, and the choke is gradually opened fully.
  6. Shut down and flow check. Stop the pump, close the choke and confirm that SIDPP and SICP are zero. Then flow-check through the choke before opening the BOP. Trapped pressure, gas below the BOP and the need to circulate with a trip margin are handled according to company procedure.

Fully worked example (illustrative)

Example: Driller's Method on a vertical well

Vertical well, MD = TVD = 9,800 ft. Original mud 10.2 ppg. 9-5/8 in casing shoe at 5,000 ft TVD, leak-off EMW 14.5 ppg. Shut in after a 15 bbl pit gain: SIDPP 480 psi, SICP 690 psi. SCR at the kill rate of 30 spm: 550 psi. Pump output 0.102 bbl/stroke.

String: 9,000 ft of 5 in drill pipe (0.01776 bbl/ft) and 800 ft of 6-1/2 in drill collars (0.0077 bbl/ft). 8-1/2 in open hole.

KMW = 10.2 + 480 ÷ (0.052 × 9,800) = 10.2 + 0.942 = 11.142 → 11.2 ppg

Formation pressure = 0.052 × 10.2 × 9,800 + 480 = 5,197.9 + 480 = 5,677.9 psi

ICP = 550 + 480 = 1,030 psi

FCP = 550 × 11.2 ÷ 10.2 = 603.9 → 604 psi

String volume = 9,000 × 0.01776 + 800 × 0.0077 = 166.0 bbl

Strokes to bit = 166.0 ÷ 0.102 = 1,627 (≈ 54 min, 30 spm)

Annulus volume = 23.3 + 183.6 + 244.6 = 451.5 bbl

Strokes bit to surface = 451.5 ÷ 0.102 = 4,427 (≈ 148 min)

MAASP (10.2 ppg) = (14.5 − 10.2) × 0.052 × 5,000 = 1,118 psi

MAASP (11.2 ppg) = (14.5 − 11.2) × 0.052 × 5,000 = 858 psi

First circulation: bring the pump to 30 spm holding casing at 690 psi; drill pipe should read 1,030 psi. Hold 1,030 psi for at least 4,427 strokes, normally a full circulation of about 6,054 strokes. Shut in: both gauges should read about 480 psi.

Second circulation: bring the pump to 30 spm holding casing at 480 psi. Hold casing at 480 psi for 1,627 strokes while drill pipe pressure falls from 1,030 to 604 psi. Then hold drill pipe at 604 psi until 11.2 ppg mud returns at surface. Shut in: both gauges read 0 psi.

With 11.2 ppg mud, bottom-hole hydrostatic is 0.052 × 11.2 × 9,800 = 5,707.5 psi, about 30 psi above formation pressure: the margin comes only from rounding KMW up.

Annular capacities in this example come from (hole ID² − pipe OD²) ÷ 1,029.4, using 8.681 in for the casing ID. The annulus total breaks down into 23.3 bbl around the collars, 183.6 bbl around the drill pipe in open hole and 244.6 bbl around the drill pipe inside the casing. These are illustrative values chosen to make the arithmetic clear, not data from a real well.

How the pressures behave, and why

PhaseHold constantDrill pipe pressureCasing pressure
Pump start-up (both circulations)Casing pressureRises to ICP (1st) or to the circulating value (2nd)Held at shut-in value
1st circulation, influx moving upDrill pipe at ICPConstantRises with gas expansion, peaks with gas at surface
1st circulation, after the influxDrill pipe at ICPConstantFalls to about the original SIDPP
2nd circulation, kill mud to bitCasing pressureFalls from ICP to FCPConstant
2nd circulation, kill mud bit to surfaceDrill pipe at FCPConstantFalls to zero

The key is the U-tube. On the side that contains only fluid of known density, the gauge is a reliable picture of bottom-hole pressure. In the first circulation that side is the drill string; in the first half of the second circulation it is the annulus; once kill mud passes the bit it is the drill string again.

When to choose the Driller's Method

Advantages

  • Circulation can start almost immediately after the pressures stabilise. This matters with gas, which can migrate if the well stays shut in.
  • Few calculations and no step-down schedule in the first circulation, which reduces errors under stress.
  • Useful when weighting material, mixing capacity or storage is limited, or when the kill mud weight is uncertain.
  • The well is free of influx after one circulation, even if the kill is then interrupted.

Disadvantages

  • Two circulations: longer time on the choke and more wear on surface equipment.
  • Annular pressures are generally higher than with Wait and Weight while the gas is circulated out, because it is circulated with the lighter original mud. Pressure at the shoe may therefore be higher, which matters when the margin to MAASP is small.

Common mistakes

  • Holding casing pressure constant during the first circulation instead of drill pipe pressure: as gas expands, bottom-hole pressure would fall and more influx would enter.
  • Bringing the pump up to speed too quickly or without holding casing pressure, which can let in a second influx or overpressure the shoe.
  • Over-correcting with the choke and not waiting for the response to reach the drill pipe gauge.
  • Forgetting to switch from casing pressure to drill pipe pressure when kill mud reaches the bit in the second circulation.
  • Treating the casing pressure rise in the first circulation as a problem and opening the choke to "bring it down": this lowers bottom-hole pressure.
  • Using MD instead of TVD for KMW, or rounding KMW down.

Practice with the site tools

Check every number above with the kill mud weight and MAASP calculators. For the formulas and rounding rules see the article on kill mud weight and on LOT, FIT and MAASP. The companion articles compare this method with the Wait and Weight Method and explain kick indicators and the shut-in procedure.

Test your understanding

Test your understanding
In the first circulation of the Driller's Method, which pressure is held constant once the pump is at kill rate?
Explanation: With original mud in the string, holding drill pipe pressure at ICP (SCR + SIDPP) keeps bottom-hole pressure constant while the influx moves up the annulus.
TVD 9,800 ft, OMW 10.2 ppg, SIDPP 480 psi. What kill mud weight goes on the kill sheet?
Explanation: 10.2 + 480 ÷ (0.052 × 9,800) = 10.2 + 0.942 = 11.142 ppg, rounded up to 11.2 ppg.
At the end of a successful first circulation the pumps are stopped and the well is shut in. What should the gauges show?
Explanation: The annulus now contains only original mud, so both sides of the U-tube balance the same formation pressure with the same mud: both read the original SIDPP (480 psi in the example).
During the second circulation, while kill mud travels from surface to the bit, what is held constant?
Explanation: The annulus contains clean original mud of known density, so a constant casing pressure means constant bottom-hole pressure. Drill pipe pressure falls by itself towards FCP.

Glossary terms

Related lessons

Open the calculators

Sources

  1. IWCF - Drilling well control formula sheet, API field units (EX-0035)
  2. IWCF - Drilling Well Control Syllabus, Level 3 and 4 (TF-0020)
  3. IADC WellSharp - Formula sheet, field units (rev. 4): kill sheet calculations and rounding
  4. API RP 59 - Recommended Practice for Well Control Operations (API standards catalogue)
  5. R. D. Grace - Blowout and Well Control Handbook, 2nd ed., Gulf Professional Publishing (2017)
  6. D. Watson, T. Brittenham, P. L. Moore - Advanced Well Control, SPE Textbook Series vol. 10 (2003)

A question about this article? Ask the library