Wait and Weight (Engineer's) Method Step by Step: Kill Sheet, ICP to FCP Schedule and Comparison with the Driller's Method
Key takeaways
- The Wait and Weight Method kills the well in one circulation: the well stays shut in while kill mud is mixed, then kill mud is pumped straight away.
- While kill mud fills the string, drill pipe pressure must follow a schedule from ICP = SCR + SIDPP down to FCP = SCR × KMW ÷ OMW. After kill mud reaches the bit, hold FCP until it returns to surface.
- Worked example: KMW 11.2 ppg, ICP 1,030 psi, FCP 604 psi, 1,627 strokes to the bit: about 26 psi per 100 strokes, or ten steps of 43 psi.
- Compared with the Driller's Method it usually gives lower annular and casing shoe pressures and less time on the choke, but needs waiting time, more calculation and enough mixing capacity.
- The step-down chart is a straight line only for a vertical well with a simple string. Deviated and horizontal wells need extra points on the schedule.
Educational content only: procedures and operating values vary between companies and wells. Always follow your company’s approved procedures, your supervisor’s instructions and the permits in force at your site.
What the Wait and Weight Method is
The Wait and Weight Method, also called the Engineer's Method, is the second standard constant bottom-hole pressure method in IWCF and IADC WellSharp drilling well control training. The well stays shut in while mud is weighted up to the kill mud weight ("wait and weight"), and then the influx is circulated out and the well is killed in a single circulation, with kill mud pumped from the first stroke.
The physics is the same as in the Driller's Method: keep bottom-hole pressure constant and slightly above formation pressure using the choke. The difference is in what is inside the drill string. Because kill mud is replacing original mud in the string while we pump, the drill pipe pressure needed to keep bottom-hole pressure constant is not fixed: it decreases as the string fills with heavier mud. That is why this method needs a pressure schedule, the step-down chart.
Step 1: the kill sheet
The kill sheet (see the kill sheet lesson) gathers the pre-recorded data and the kick data, then the calculations:
- Pre-recorded: TVD and MD, OMW, string and annular capacities, pump output, SCR at one or two kill rates for each pump, shoe TVD and test EMW.
- Kick data: stabilised SIDPP and SICP, pit gain, time of shut-in.
- Calculations: KMW, ICP, FCP, strokes surface to bit and bit to surface, the step-down schedule, MAASP with original and with kill mud.
KMW (ppg) = OMW + SIDPP ÷ (0.052 × TVD) (round up)
ICP (psi) = SCR + SIDPP
FCP (psi) = SCR × KMW ÷ OMW
Pressure drop per step = (ICP − FCP) ÷ number of steps
FCP is the circulating pressure with kill mud in the string and no SIDPP left to overcome: the frictional pressure loss rises in proportion to mud density, hence SCR × KMW ÷ OMW.
Step 2: building the step-down schedule
Divide the surface-to-bit strokes into equal steps (ten is common) and calculate the drill pipe pressure at the end of each step. For a vertical well with a uniform string, pressure falls linearly with strokes.
Fully worked example (illustrative)
Same illustrative well as in the Driller's Method article: vertical, MD = TVD = 9,800 ft; OMW 10.2 ppg; shoe at 5,000 ft TVD with test EMW 14.5 ppg; SIDPP 480 psi, SICP 690 psi, pit gain 15 bbl; SCR 550 psi at 30 spm; pump output 0.102 bbl/stroke; string volume 166.0 bbl; annulus volume 451.5 bbl.
KMW = 10.2 + 480 ÷ (0.052 × 9,800) = 11.142 → 11.2 ppg
ICP = 550 + 480 = 1,030 psi
FCP = 550 × 11.2 ÷ 10.2 = 603.9 → 604 psi
Strokes surface to bit = 166.0 ÷ 0.102 = 1,627 strokes (≈ 54 min at 30 spm)
Strokes bit to surface = 451.5 ÷ 0.102 = 4,427 strokes (≈ 148 min)
Drop per step = (1,030 − 604) ÷ 10 = 42.6 psi
Strokes per step = 1,627 ÷ 10 = 162.7 (≈ 26.2 psi per 100 strokes)
MAASP with kill mud = (14.5 − 11.2) × 0.052 × 5,000 = 858 psi
| Step | Strokes | Drill pipe pressure (psi) |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 1,030 |
| 1 | 163 | 987 |
| 2 | 325 | 945 |
| 3 | 488 | 902 |
| 4 | 651 | 860 |
| 5 | 814 | 817 |
| 6 | 976 | 774 |
| 7 | 1,139 | 732 |
| 8 | 1,302 | 689 |
| 9 | 1,464 | 647 |
| 10 | 1,627 | 604 |
Values are rounded to the nearest psi and stroke. The open-hole annular volume in this example is 23.3 + 183.6 = 206.9 bbl, larger than the 166.0 bbl string volume. Kill mud therefore reaches the bit and starts up the annulus before the top of the influx can pass the shoe, which is the situation where this method gives a real reduction in shoe pressure.
Step 3: the single circulation
- Wait and weigh. Keep the well shut in and monitor SIDPP and SICP while mud is weighted up. A steady rise of both pressures after stabilisation suggests gas migration; if it continues, it must be controlled (for example by the volumetric method) according to company procedure.
- Start the pump holding casing pressure constant. Bring the pump up to the kill rate while opening the choke to keep casing pressure at SICP. Kill mud is already entering the string.
- Confirm ICP. At kill rate, drill pipe pressure should read ICP (1,030 psi in the example). If it differs, stop to investigate; if the cause is an inaccurate SCR, many procedures recalculate the schedule from the observed ICP: FCP = (observed ICP − SIDPP) × KMW ÷ OMW.
- Follow the schedule to the bit. Adjust the choke so drill pipe pressure follows the table step by step as the stroke counter advances. The choke operator works to the table; another person calls out strokes and target pressures.
- Hold FCP from bit to surface. Once kill mud reaches the bit, hold drill pipe pressure at FCP. Casing pressure changes as gas expands and kill mud rises; it should not be held constant.
- Shut down and check. When kill mud returns at the choke, stop the pump holding casing pressure, then confirm SIDPP and SICP are zero and flow-check before opening the BOP.
Comparison with the Driller's Method
| Item | Driller's Method | Wait and Weight Method |
|---|---|---|
| Circulations | Two | One |
| Start of circulation | Almost immediate | After kill mud is ready |
| Calculations during the kill | Simple: fixed ICP, then fixed FCP | Step-down schedule from ICP to FCP |
| Maximum casing pressure | Generally higher | Generally lower, once kill mud enters the annulus before the gas reaches surface |
| Pressure at the casing shoe | May be higher | Lower or equal (see the volume check above) |
| Time on the choke and wear | Longer | Shorter |
| Risk while shut in | Lower (short wait) | Gas migration while weighting up |
| Logistics | Can start with limited mixing capacity | Needs enough weighting material and mixing capacity |
Neither method is "always better". Many operators specify in their well control policy which method is preferred and under what conditions; some use the Driller's Method by default for its simplicity and fast start, others prefer Wait and Weight when the margin between MAASP and SICP is small.
Deviated and horizontal wells
In a deviated well, the hydrostatic gain from kill mud depends on TVD while the friction and the volume depend on MD. As kill mud passes through the build and tangent sections, drill pipe pressure does not fall in a straight line. Using a straight schedule in such a well can leave bottom-hole pressure too high in the middle of the displacement. The kill sheet then calculates intermediate points, for example at the kick-off point and end of build, using the TVD and MD of each point. Follow the method in the kill sheet format your company and certification body use.
Common mistakes
- Using SICP instead of SIDPP in KMW or ICP.
- Starting the pump while holding drill pipe pressure instead of casing pressure.
- Following the schedule against time instead of against strokes, or with a stroke counter that was not reset when kill mud reached the drill floor. Surface line volume must be taken into account.
- Holding casing pressure constant after kill mud reaches the bit.
- Forgetting to recalculate MAASP with kill mud.
- Applying a linear schedule to a highly deviated or horizontal well.
Practice with the site tools
Use the kill mud weight calculator, which also returns ICP and FCP from the SCR, and the MAASP calculator on the same page. For the formulas and rounding rules see kill mud weight and LOT, FIT and MAASP. The first steps of any kill, detecting the kick and shutting in, are covered in kick indicators and the shut-in procedure.
Test your understanding
Glossary terms
Related lessons
- Kill Sheet Step-by-Step: Driller's Method or Wait and Weight?
- Formation Pressure: Normal, Subnormal, and Abnormal
- Gas Migration in a Shut-in Well
- Well Pressure Fundamentals
Sources
- IWCF - Drilling well control formula sheet, API field units (EX-0035)
- IWCF - Drilling Well Control Syllabus, Level 3 and 4 (TF-0020)
- IADC WellSharp - Formula sheet, field units (rev. 4): kill sheet calculations and rounding
- API RP 59 - Recommended Practice for Well Control Operations (API standards catalogue)
- R. D. Grace - Blowout and Well Control Handbook, 2nd ed., Gulf Professional Publishing (2017)
- D. Watson, T. Brittenham, P. L. Moore - Advanced Well Control, SPE Textbook Series vol. 10 (2003)
A question about this article? Ask the library