Kick Indicators and the Shut-In Procedure: Hard vs Soft Shut-In, Reading SIDPP and SICP, and Gas Migration Basics
Key takeaways
- Positive indicators (pit gain, increased return flow, flow with the pumps off) mean shut in. Warning signs (drilling break, pump pressure drop, gas-cut mud and others) mean stop and flow-check.
- Hard shut-in: BOP closed against a closed choke, the fastest way to stop the influx. Soft shut-in: choke open, closed after the BOP. Your company's well control policy defines which one is used.
- Record SIDPP, SICP, pit gain and time once pressures stabilise. SIDPP gives formation pressure and kill mud weight; SICP minus SIDPP hints at the influx type.
- Illustrative example: SIDPP 480 psi, SICP 690 psi, 15 bbl gain around 6-1/2 in collars in 8-1/2 in hole: influx gradient about 0.12 psi/ft, most likely gas.
- In a shut-in well a gas bubble that migrates without expanding carries its pressure up: SIDPP and SICP rise together and can break down the shoe. Migration must be controlled, never ignored.
Educational content only: procedures and operating values vary between companies and wells. Always follow your company’s approved procedures, your supervisor’s instructions and the permits in force at your site.
Why seconds matter
Every barrel of formation fluid that enters the well before it is closed in makes the kill harder: higher shut-in pressures, higher casing pressure when gas reaches surface, and a higher pressure at the casing shoe. The most important well control skill is therefore not a calculation: it is to recognise the kick early and close the well correctly. Everything in the Driller's Method and the Wait and Weight Method starts from the numbers read after shut-in.
Kick indicators while drilling
Well control training separates two kinds of signal (see the lesson on kick warning signs).
Positive indicators: the well is flowing, shut in.
- Pit gain: pit volume increases with no mud added at surface.
- Increased return flow: the flow-out sensor reads more than the pumps are delivering at a constant rate.
- Flow with the pumps off: the well keeps flowing during a flow check.
Warning signs: something has changed, stop and flow-check.
- Drilling break: a sudden increase in rate of penetration, which may mean a more porous or higher-pressure formation.
- Pump pressure decrease with pump stroke increase: lighter fluid in the annulus reduces the pressure the pump must overcome.
- Gas-cut mud, increased background or connection gas, or a change in mud properties such as chlorides.
- Changes in cuttings size or shape, and increased torque or drag, which can indicate an underbalanced, overpressured interval.
With oil-based mud, gas can dissolve in the mud at bottom-hole conditions. The pit gain may be small until the gas comes out of solution near surface, then grows quickly. Small changes must be taken seriously.
Kick indicators while tripping
A large share of kicks is associated with tripping. The trip tank is the primary tool:
- Pulling out: the hole must take the steel (or closed-end) displacement of the pipe pulled. If it takes less, formation fluid may be entering, for example through swabbing.
- Running in: the returns must equal the displacement of the pipe run. More returns than expected means the well may be flowing.
- Keep a trip sheet and compare actual with calculated volumes every few stands.
The shut-in procedure while drilling
The exact sequence is defined by the rig's well control bridging document and the operator's policy. A typical hard shut-in while drilling is:
- Stop rotating and pick up off bottom to the space-out position, so that no tool joint is across the BOP element or ram to be closed.
- Stop the pumps.
- Flow-check if the signal was only a warning sign. If the indicator is positive, go straight to shut-in.
- Close the annular preventer (or the pipe ram, per policy).
- Open the hydraulically operated choke line valve (HCR) with the choke closed.
- Inform the supervisor, record the time, read and record SIDPP, SICP and the pit gain, and then read pressures at regular intervals, for example every minute, until they stabilise.
- Check the BOP, choke manifold and surface lines for leaks.
Hard or soft shut-in?
| Item | Hard shut-in | Soft shut-in |
|---|---|---|
| Choke during drilling | Closed | Open, with the line-up to the choke |
| Sequence | Close BOP, open HCR | Open HCR, close BOP, close choke |
| Speed | Faster | Slower: one more step |
| Influx volume | Smaller | Slightly larger |
| Pressure surge on closure | The well is closed instantly, so a pressure pulse is possible | Reduced by closing the choke last |
Many operators and current training courses favour the hard shut-in because it minimises influx volume. Full-scale tests on an instrumented test well, published as SPE/IADC 25712 (1993), found that the extra pressure reaching the formation from a hard shut-in was negligible, while the soft shut-in let in more influx. Some policies still specify the soft shut-in, for example in particular shallow or weak-formation situations. Follow the procedure your company has approved and practise it in drills until it is automatic.
Shut-in while tripping
- Set the pipe on the slips with a tool joint at working height.
- Install the full-opening safety valve (FOSV) in the open position, then close it.
- Close the BOP and open the HCR (hard shut-in).
- Record SICP, pit gain and time, and inform the supervisor.
- If needed, an inside BOP can then be installed above the FOSV for stripping, per procedure.
Installing the valve open is essential: if the pipe is flowing, a closed valve cannot be stabbed against the flow.
Reading SIDPP and SICP
After shut-in, pressures rise and then level off as the well and the formation reach equilibrium. The time this takes depends on the permeability and on the type of influx. Record the stabilised values and their time.
Formation pressure = SIDPP + 0.052 × OMW × TVD
KMW = OMW + SIDPP ÷ (0.052 × TVD)
Why SIDPP and not SICP? The drill string contains only mud of known density; the annulus contains the influx of unknown density and height. SIDPP is a direct measure of underbalance. SICP is normally higher, because the lighter influx reduces the annulus hydrostatic.
Float in the string. A non-ported float valve stops the drill pipe gauge seeing pressure. To read SIDPP, pump very slowly into the drill pipe with the well shut in. Watch drill pipe and casing pressures: when the float opens, casing pressure begins to rise. The drill pipe pressure just before that moment is SIDPP.
Trapped pressure. If the pump was not stopped before closure, or the pressures were recorded too long after stabilisation, readings can be too high. Procedures describe how to bleed small volumes through the choke to check for trapped pressure.
SIDPP 480 psi, SICP 690 psi, pit gain 15 bbl, OMW 10.2 ppg. The influx sits around the 6-1/2 in collars in 8-1/2 in hole, annular capacity 0.02914 bbl/ft.
Influx height = 15 ÷ 0.02914 = 514.7 ft
Influx gradient = 0.052 × 10.2 − (690 − 480) ÷ 514.7 = 0.530 − 0.408 = 0.12 psi/ft
A gradient of about 0.12 psi/ft points to gas. Oil or water would give a gradient much closer to that of the mud. This estimate is rough: the influx is rarely a single clean slug, and hole washouts change the real height.
Gas migration basics
Gas is lighter than mud and tends to rise even when the well is shut in. In an ideal case, a bubble that cannot expand (closed well, incompressible mud) keeps its original pressure as it rises. The bubble now applies formation pressure at a shallower depth, plus the mud column below it, so pressure increases everywhere in the well: SIDPP and SICP rise together, and pressure at the shoe and at the bottom rises too.
After stabilising, SIDPP and SICP both rise by 100 psi in 30 minutes, with 10.2 ppg mud.
Mud gradient = 0.052 × 10.2 = 0.5304 psi/ft
Distance risen ≈ 100 ÷ 0.5304 = 188.5 ft in 30 min, about 377 ft/h
If nothing is done, the rising pressure can exceed the MAASP and break down the shoe. Gas migration is controlled either by starting to circulate (for example the Driller's Method) or, when circulation is not possible, by the volumetric method, which bleeds measured volumes of mud through the choke to let the gas expand in a controlled way while keeping bottom-hole pressure within a planned range. Never bleed off gas pressure without a method: bleeding without control lets in more influx. See the lesson on gas migration.
Common mistakes
- Flow-checking for a long time when a positive indicator is already present.
- Closing the BOP on a tool joint because the string was not spaced out.
- Forgetting to open the HCR in a hard shut-in, so SICP is not seen.
- Stabbing the FOSV closed while the pipe is flowing.
- Taking SIDPP as zero with a float in the string.
- Waiting for "perfectly stable" pressures while gas migrates and readings creep up.
Practice
Use the kill mud weight and MAASP calculators with your own SIDPP and SICP readings, and review the lessons on causes of a kick and BOP equipment.
Test your understanding
Glossary terms
Related lessons
- Warning Signs: How to Detect a Kick Early
- The Kick: Causes and Initiation
- Gas Migration in a Shut-in Well
- BOP Equipment: Types and Closure Methods
Sources
- IWCF - Drilling Well Control Syllabus, Level 3 and 4 (TF-0020)
- IWCF - Drilling well control formula sheet, API field units (EX-0035)
- API RP 59 - Recommended Practice for Well Control Operations (API standards catalogue)
- SPE/IADC 25712 (1993) - Hard or Soft Shut-In: Which Is the Best Approach? (OnePetro abstract)
- R. D. Grace - Blowout and Well Control Handbook, 2nd ed., Gulf Professional Publishing (2017)
- D. Watson, T. Brittenham, P. L. Moore - Advanced Well Control, SPE Textbook Series vol. 10 (2003)
A question about this article? Ask the library